End of Trade Unions funding personal injury claims?

Trade Unions have a long tradition of supporting personal injury claims

I started my legal career with Thompsons and also worked for Russell Jones & Walker. They are just two firms which receive many cases through referral from Trade Unions. Claimants are represented under Collective Conditional Fee Agreements (CCFA). If the claim is successful the claimant can recover from the defendant a sum which is payable to the Union – in lieu of a premium in a CFA case. If unsuccessful the Union will pay the defendant’s costs on behalf of their member. As union solicitors win/settle the vast majority of their cases this is in fact a source of revenue for the Union.

I wonder then what they make of the proposals in the recent report by Lord Jackson on qualified one-way costs shifting? The idea is that the traditional rule of paying the defendant’s costs if you lose be abolished and replaced with this proposal quoted from page 189 of the report:

4.7 Proposed rule. I therefore propose that all claimants in personal injury cases, whether or not legally aided, be given a broadly similar degree of protection against adverse costs. In order to achieve this result I propose that a provision along the following lines be added to the CPR:

“Costs ordered against the claimant in any claim for personal injuries or clinical negligence shall not Read More »

Jackson report debated in parliament

The Lords get the debate underway

The House of Lords has had the briefest debate about the Jackson report on costs reform. You don’t have to go to the law library as Hansards comes to you on line – you can see the debate here.

Not a lot was said other than the fact that the government is now “actively assessing the implications” of the report. Lord Woolf asked how long it will be before we see any action taken. He may as well have asked how long is a piece of string. Lord Bach informed the House that the report requires a great deal of analysis and wondered if Lord Jackson wanted all the recommendations implementing as a package or not implementing at all!

Oh, and by the way, there’s an election coming up so don’t hold your breath.

Do you think Sir Rupert’s report has to be implemented in full or should the Ministry of Justice cherry pick the recommendations?

Mediation posts from the archive

A look back at articles from the archive of February 2009 covering client care, HSE myth busting and lawyers and negotiation skills.

Read the full article »

LinkedIn personal injury group

Introducing a new LinkedIn group for all professionals involved in personal injury claims.

Read the full article »

Wildlake v BAA Ltd 2009

Should personal injury claimants who exaggerate their claims be penalised in costs even when they hae beaten the defendants part 36 offer? Lord Justice Ward gives his verdict in Wildlake v BAA Ltd 2009.

Read the full article »

Hullock v East Riding of Yorkshire County Council

Once again the question of who was the winner in personal injury litigation was considered by the Court of Appeal in Hullock v East Riding of Yorkshire County Council [2009]. In December 2004 the claimant tripped on a pavement and suffered injuries. She had a fractured hip requiring insertion of a plate and two weeks [...]

Read the full article »

Education key to mediation growth

Follow the link on this page to my latest article in the Personal Injury Brief Update Journal on comments made by Lord Clarke supporting mediation in personal injury litigation.

Read the full article »

Jackson Costs review final report

Follow this link to read Lord Justice Jackson’s review of civil costs final report. Feel free to comment below. I have extracted the relevant personal injury parts of the executive summary and will comment on them in future posts.
Proposals from the executive summary:

General damages to be increased by 10%.
Success fees and ATE premiums should cease [...]

Read the full article »

Who pays for personal injury mediation?

The mediator’s fee is usually split between the parties and paid in advance. However insurers are increasingly offering to pay the whole fee to encourage or enable the claimant to attend.

Read the full article »

Beresfords former solicitors lose appeal

Former solicitors lose appeal against being struck off the Roll whilst some MPs call for solicitors to be excluded from proposed scheme for asbestos related pleural plaques compensation.

Read the full article »